Should Ender’s Game be judged by it’s author?
Ever had a hard time reconciling your feelings about Ender’s Game, the author who wrote it, and the ideas that he expounds in other venues? Did those ideas somehow shape the content of the book? And if so, is it appropriate to appreciate a book out of the context of which it was written, or can it stand alone and transcend the author’s political views?
Matt Blum @ Wired dealt with OSC’s position on same-sex marriage, asserting that “We need a way to gauge the quality of a person’s work against whatever repugnant thing(s) they’ve done.”
I’ll let you be the judge on that one; make your own analysis on the arguments outlined in either of these articles. Is his analysis on OSC’s arguments correct or fair? Are OSC’s outlined implications for democracy just a thinly veiled disguise for an ideological attack on gay rights activists? Perhaps it’s a bit of both. But regardless of the truth of this particular argument, even if OSC were a gay-bashing religious zealot that only used language to manipulate his readers with red herrings to further his agenda, would that mean we should throw the baby out with the bathwater?
I think it’s a fair question. Can we judge a work out of the context in which it was created; or can we reinterpret the work in it’s more modern context, apart from the author’s evolving policial ideas? If the story stands alone as a work that can be applied to the world we live in, shouldn’t we take all the other stuff with a grain of salt? Or are we better off seeing the whole picture, even if it’s distorted by the layered lenses of perception? After all, the real power of storytelling, whether it come from a bible or a science fiction eipc, is in it’s osmosis-like ability to help us learn about and navigate the world around us.
So if Ender’s Game teaches us about the world we live in, what are the lessons?
If you’re a fan of Futurama (and we can only assume you’re an Ender’s Game fan if you’re reading this), than the working title of one of four upcoming Futurama movies should catch your attention: Futurama: Bender’s Game.